2024 Nerevu Group, LLC, All rights reserved. i
The research workforce
Nerve Group (pronounced {nay-RAY-voo}) is an information analytics firm that helps organizations uncover insights hidden of their knowledge in actual time. With a deal with improvement, knowledge intelligence and knowledge technique, Nerevu leads its shoppers into the data-driven future. By automating guide processes, simplifying enterprise evaluation, and integrating knowledge silos, Nerevu allows its prospects to enhance their operations and drive progress.
CW Monetary and Administration Group, is a Service Disabled Veterans Small Enterprise (SDVOSB) primarily based in Illinois. Illinois State Central Administration Companies Minority-Owned Small Enterprise, CWFM Group helps shoppers clear up advanced challenges and create the outcomes they want. With experience in accounting, budgeting, auditing, design and course of enchancment, healthcare administration, monetary evaluation, provide chain administration, and lots of different areas of administration, CWFM Group served as director of mission for the Illinois Grownup Use Hashish Business Disparity Research.
The Legislation Workplaces of Dorsey, PC (DLO) is an MBE from the Licensed Enterprise Enterprise Program in Illinois who focuses his follow on offering authorities shoppers with coverage improvement and regulatory implication evaluation. DLO assists each public and chosen non-public organizations with feasibility evaluation, property retention, acquisition and transportation, and relationship administration companies that facilitate consumer objectives and targets. By means of his principal, he is part of the Illinois State Bar and is licensed within the Federal Court docket of the Federal District of Central Illinois. With in depth expertise, DLO has supplied the instrumental evaluation for the exact articulation of basic points for the formulation and implementation of acceptable authorized methods.
Tanoma Consulting, LLC is a nationwide consulting agency that gives analysis, analysis and culturally responsive transformative capability constructing companies to advance well being, schooling and workforce fairness by means of a racial justice and fairness lens emphasizing holistic, upstream, trauma-informed and empathy-building. Led by Lisa Aponte-Soto, Ph.D., MHA, Tanoma's disparities analysis workforce included Ana Herrera, Ph.D., MPH, Emely Medina-Rodríguez, Ph.D., MA, Mislael Valentín-Cortés, MPH, MSW, Ph.D., Maya Diaz, MA, Haley Beck, MA, Paola Torres, MPH, Riley Coesens, and Javier Arellano.
Utilized Economics Clinic (AEC) is a mission-based non-profit consulting group providing skilled companies within the areas of power, setting, client safety and fairness. The AEC workforce, beneath the management of Elizabeth A. Stanton, Ph.D., included Bryndis Woods, Ph.D., Tanya Stasio, Ph.D., Jordan Burt, Deja Garraway, Nayantara Biswas, and Alannah Shute.
Richard M. Juang, JDis an legal professional with the Legislation Workplaces of Richard M. Juang.
Jean Lacy is a coverage skilled, impartial marketing consultant, and the Founding father of the Illinois Psychedelic Society, advocating for protected entry and a sane and equitable drug coverage in Illinois.
Acknowledgment
We wish to specific particular appreciation to Erin Johnson, Solomon Hatch, Kirsten Davis-Franklin, and Nathaniel Inglis Steinfeld and the employees of the Illinois Division of Monetary and Skilled Regulation, the Illinois Division of Agriculture, and the employees of the Illinois Division of Commerce and Economics. Alternatives for his or her help in finishing up this research. Further because of Colette Holt. Most significantly, we’d additionally wish to thank the main target group members and the broader hashish neighborhood for his or her invaluable contributions and dedication to furthering our analysis efforts.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In June 2019, Illinois handed the Hashish Regulation and Taxation Act (CRTA) to supply advantages and enterprise alternatives “to people most immediately and adversely affected by the enforcement of legal guidelines associated to the hashish which might be eager about beginning hashish enterprise institutions”.1 Acknowledged by the Governor and Normal Meeting, the disproportionate influence of hashish prohibition on racial and ethnic minority communities fueled the drafting of the CRTA and a coverage to advertise fairness and funding in these communities.2 The race-neutral coverage, often known as social fairness, included provisions for neighborhood reinvestment, funding and assist for brand new entrants into the hashish market, and the elimination of felony circumstances associated to possession of hashish as much as sure quantities.3,4
1 Illinois Normal Meeting, “410 ILCS 705/7-1 Hashish Regulation and Tax Act,” June 25, 2019, accessed November 17, 2023, https://www.ilga.gov/laws/ilcs/ilcs5.asp? ActID= 3992.
2 State of Illinois, “Gov. Pritzker Indicators Most Fairness-Centric Legislation in Nation to Legalize Grownup-Use Hashish”, 25 June 2019, accessed December 11, 2023, https://www.illinois.gov/information/press-release. 20242.html.
3 Chapter III BACKGROUND gives an in depth historical past of the CRTA.
4 Chapter IV REGULATION OF CANNABIS IN ILLINOIS gives an in depth evaluation of the social fairness provisions of the CRTA.
The CRTA legalized the sale of hashish for grownup use in early 2020. By the tip of 2022, the State of Illinois had granted greater than 550 hashish licenses for the usage of adults at greater than 400 companies, most of which have been owned by ladies or racial and/or ethnic. minorities
Pursuant to the CRTA, the Hashish Regulatory Oversight Officer (CROO) has chosen Nerevu Group (Nerevu) to conduct a disparity research to evaluate “whether or not there may be discrimination within the State's hashish business of Illinois” and in case, “consider the influence of such discrimination” and supply “suggestions to cut back or eradicate any recognized boundaries to entry into the hashish market.”5
5 Illinois Normal Meeting, “410 ILCS 705/5-45(e) Hashish Regulation and Tax Act,” June 25, 2019, accessed November 17, 2023, https://www.ilga.gov/laws/ilcs /ilcs5.asp ?ActID=3992.
We analyzed all 5 sorts of hashish license for adults – dishing out organizations, craft growers, infusion organizations, transport organizations and cultivation facilities – in all licensing rounds within the research interval from 1 January 2020 to January 31, 2023. This in-depth evaluation supplied insights into the distribution and disparities within the licensing means of the hashish business in Illinois.
A. Authorized Framework
As mandated by the CRTA, this disparity research conforms to the authorized foundations established by the US Supreme Court docket, that are outlined in federal pointers and utilized in earlier Illinois State disparity research.6 Beneath the Equal Safety Clause of the Fourteenth Modification to the US Structure, no state shall deny to any individual inside its jurisdiction the equal safety of the legal guidelines. Normally, authorities insurance policies ought to face up to “shut scrutiny” or “intermediate scrutiny.”
6 Chapter II STUDIES OF DISPARITY LEGAL STANDARDS present an in depth description of the authorized framework relevant to the research.
ILLINOIS ADULT USE CANNABIS INDUSTRY DISPARITY STUDIES REPORT 2024
© 2024 Nerevu Group, LLC, All rights reserved. 2
survive constitutional challenges relating to race or gender discrimination. In Metropolis of Richmond v. J. A. Croson Co., the Supreme Court docket has outlined the “strict scrutiny” commonplace for reviewing authorities insurance policies primarily based on race, which requires a compelling authorities curiosity in adopting such a coverage and a treatment narrowly tailor-made to additional the curiosity of the federal government.7 Gender-based insurance policies face “intermediate scrutiny” evaluation, requiring a very persuasive justification and a considerable relationship between the coverage and its goal.8 For this research, we make use of a rigorous evaluation much like strict scrutiny for elements of race and gender, making certain a complete examination of disparities and informing corrective measures within the Illinois hashish business. As well as, we focus on the rational foundation scrutiny and its applicability to classifications, corresponding to social fairness candidates (SEA), which aren’t associated to race, ethnicity, faith, nationwide origin or gender.
As outlined in Chapter II. LEGAL STANDARDS OF DISPARITY STUDIES, it’s essential to differentiate between disparity and discrimination. Disparity refers to a number of quantifiable distinction(s) between two or extra outlined teams.9 Within the context of this analysis, we examined disparities between totally different teams of members to find out whether or not the market composition precisely displays the variety of prepared, prepared and in a position market members.10
Discrimination is the unfair or prejudicial remedy of individuals primarily based on race, ethnicity, spiritual beliefs, navy standing, gender identification, and many others.11 This contains systemic obstacles, specific insurance policies, and the absence thereof, which might result in unequal entry to alternatives, companies, programs and sources, thus producing a disparate influence, such because the inequitable distribution of licenses12
On this research, we gathered in depth quantitative knowledge from varied sources—federal, state, and personal. We then analyzed the demographics of the Illinois hashish and associated industries and recognized disparities by race, ethnicity and/or gender within the Illinois hashish business relative to acceptable comparability teams. We complemented this evaluation with qualitative knowledge from 200 business executives, hashish licensees and hashish license candidates who participated in a sequence of interviews and focus teams.
We additionally analyzed survey outcomes from hashish licensees and candidates to establish whether or not the disparities have been the results of discrimination. The evaluation incorporates greater than 200 survey responses from the 2023 CROO Range Survey and a separate survey for hashish candidates, for a complete of 216 responses. Total, the CROO Survey knowledge concerned 156 responses, whereas the Nerevu Survey included 60 responses, every contributing to a complete overview of the hashish business by 2023.
1720877137166
