-
Naval mines may very well be an affordable however helpful addition to Taiwan's defenses.
-
Consultants argued that for Taiwan to develop a “porcupine” technique, and mines may very well be key.
-
However they’d not be a catch-all protection, and there are a lot of difficulties to navigate when deploying mines.
Confronted with an aggressive China that’s keen to make use of power to realize the unification it has sought for many years, Taiwan wants robust methods to discourage, and if it involves preventing, defend.
One aspect of that robust protection, specialists argue, may very well be one of many most cost-effective naval techniques: sea mines. Explosives hidden underwater may very well be key to derailing an amphibious assault and waging uneven warfare towards China's superior navy.
Consultants say naval mines may very well be very helpful in stopping the Chinese language Individuals's Liberation Military Navy or, on the very least, creating main complications throughout an invasion.
“Strategically positioned naval mines permit Taiwan to take advantage of its pure geographic benefits to strengthen deterrence by way of denial and construct a formidable protection in depth,” specialists and analysts wrote in a put up for Conflict on the Rocks earlier than the month.
“Profiting from Taiwan's shallow waters and treacherous shoreline, mines deployed at numerous water depths and places supply Taiwan a low-cost and efficient technique of delaying, disrupting and degrading Chinese language forces,” mentioned Jonathan Dorsey, Kelly Grieco and Jennifer Kavanagh.
The mines power Chinese language ships to deal with the explosive menace earlier than pushing ahead. Ships reminiscent of minesweepers may very well be despatched to clear the mines, however that effort would take time and will delay and hinder China's assault plans.
The mines gained't resolve all of Taiwan's issues, however as half of a bigger “porcupine” technique, which US officers and specialists have talked about up to now, it may very well be fairly efficient.
The thought of a “porcupine” protection may embody a “giant variety of small issues,” particularly uneven platforms that, when combined with high-cost joint power programs reminiscent of superior fighter jets and drones, present efficient deterrence and protection.
Within the occasion of a Chinese language invasion of Taiwan, “the objective ought to be to offer essential time for extra US firepower to be introduced in, and to scale back the variety of PLA forces that may be focused in highway or defeat on the water's edge,” Scott Savitz, a senior RAND engineer, wrote final yr. “Naval mines are one such functionality, complementing numerous different weapons.”
Sea mines have lengthy been a helpful technique to deny enemy entry to an space. Because the three specialists wrote of their commentary on the Conflict on the Rocks, 9 mines blocked French warships from the port of Tamsui in northern Taiwan in October 1884 through the Sino-French Conflict.
They had been generally used within the World Wars and posed main threats to warships.
Extra just lately, sea mines have seen heavy use within the Sea of Azov and the Black Sea through the battle in Ukraine, damaging and destroying ships and making the already harmful waters much more precarious. Ukraine and Russia have used these weapons, which pose a danger not solely to army operations, but additionally to civilian industrial actions.
This speaks to the bigger issues that naval mines pose. Whereas they are often an efficient deterrent, they may also be a menace to the encircling setting and civilians, and may very well be troublesome to take away. They will additionally slip in a storm or tough waters and drift lengthy distances, resulting in surprising problems.
For Taiwan, one other drawback right here is the procurement and distribution of mines. It could take a significant effort to prioritize such an effort and it isn’t clear how China would react if such actions had been noticed.
In 2022, Taiwan added minesweepers to its fleet as instruments to strengthen its protection. On the time, for the AP, Lieutenant Hsu Shu-wei of the Second Mine Operations Squadron mentioned that the weapons had been to “construct our uneven battle energy” and forestall “the enemy from reaching our island”.
However, extra capabilities might be required to completely make use of a naval mine protection.
“Though the mines considerably strengthen Taiwan's deterrence and protection, Taipei has not made the required preparations.” Dorsey, Grieco and Kavanagh mentioned of their commentary, stressing that “investing within the vital capabilities and bettering readiness to conduct mining operations” ought to be “high priorities for Taiwan.”
Learn the unique article on Enterprise Insider
